Have had this for a couple of days now. Not long enough to comment on reliability, but otherwise…
The main area where the service is let down is the guide data. Repeats aren’t always marked as such — for example Four Corners’ ABC1 repeat isn’t marked as a repeat so a season pass for Four Corners on ABC1 will get you both runs.
It’s not specific to channels. Ten has some of this right — this week’s SVU is a rerun and is marked as such, this week’s House is also a rerun and is not marked. IceTV has got this consistently right for quite a while now with no co-operation from the networks, TiVo should be able to do so as well — this is not the US, there aren’t hundreds of channels to handle and anyone who is paying attention can tell if an upcoming episode is a re-run without needing to have that flagged by the network.
To add insult to injury, the online Yahoo7 guide gets this right!
My other concern is with how consecutive recordings are handled. The software is fairly naive — if you’re recording shows X and Y consecutively on the same channel it’ll use the second tuner for the second show. Which is a bit of an issue if that’s already in use.
They’ve got a reasonable system for conflict resolution, but this is one of those cases where I’ve gotten used to the way TED+ handles this when it sets up timers on a Topfield PVR: it’ll set up a single timer event for both shows so while they’re both in a single file you’re only using a single tuner to get there.
With TiVo what you get is one of the consecutive recordings being truncated. The content is still there — it’ll be in the next recording — but it does rather break the flow of the program.
A better way to handle this would be to write the overlapping portion to both files from a single tuner. Fairly simple conceptually but how difficult it would be to implement would depend on how they’ve structured their code.
Some option to change the default pre- and post- padding times would be nice. You can enable post-padding but it’s a simple on/off, and for some reason doesn’t get switched on for ABC channels. Unfortunately not only do our commercial networks often run late, even when they do run “on time” they have different ideas about what that means. So you generally want to start 3-5 minutes early all the time. You can change this yourself per season pass or recording, but it’d be lovely to be able to set defaults in more detail.
Anyway, other than the guide data being a bit off I’m pretty happy with the device. More storage would be nice, and it’s a pity they’re holding off on releasing the extender units here — I’m a bit dubious about replacing the internal disk while it’s still under warranty. The lack of network media stuff doesn’t bother me much but then I’ve got a hacked AppleTV for that.
One final note: this device doesn’t seem to get particularly hot, which is a nice change from the old Topfield unit.
Popularity: 35% [?]
Tags: TiVo by matt
2 Comments »